The Deal Behind the Art

A two part conversation on what an auction house and a lawyer each see when art changes hands.
Libia Elena Nahas is Senior Vice President and Business Development Director for Christie’s Southeast Region, based in Miami. Daniel Novela is a corporate and art lawyer and the founder of Novela Law, a transactional law firm in Miami. He also founded Alevon, an art rental marketplace, and in 2015 the NovelaWatch Collectors Club, which brings collectors together with the people behind the watches. In the first half of the conversation, Daniel asked Libia what an auction house sees when a work of art comes to it. In the second, Libia turned the questions around and asked Daniel what the paperwork reveals.
Part One: What the Auction House Sees
Daniel Novela asks Libia Elena Nahas
Everyone hears about Christie’s as one of the major auction houses. What is unique about Christie’s here in Miami?
My role here in Miami is not what most people picture when they think of an auction house. You picture a specialist in a department, sourcing property for sale and being an expert on the object. I did that for many years. This is my 20th year at auction, 16 of them at Christie’s and 11 here in Miami. Early in my career I was a senior specialist in a quite nerdy department, Prints and Multiples, so I was extremely object focused. In Miami, while I have not forgotten my specialist roots, I am client focused rather than object focused. I help clients with appraisals, with sourcing for their collections, and with introductions to local institutions when that is what they need. It is a thousand different things on any given day.
People look at Miami as before and after Art Basel arrived. How does the Miami collector differ from collectors in New York or the other places you have worked, and how has that changed while you have been here?
The historic Miami collector who helped put Miami on the map before Art Basel is still here, and is still the foundation of Miami. But there has been a huge influx of clients, especially since Covid, and that has changed the Miami collector quite significantly. Tastes are arriving from West Coast collectors and from many Northeast collectors, and what people collect is broadening. We have serious collectors in the luxury categories, where before we were more heavily focused on art. On any given day I am talking to a collector who is interested in a postwar painting, a watch and a car.
In the watch world I see private sales growing against auction sales, and private sales are becoming a bigger part of the auction houses’ business. How do you counsel clients on what is better for them, auction or private sale?
It is a real balancing act. We would like to fit the platform to the client’s needs, but sometimes the object itself dictates which platform is right. Do we know there is real interest in that object, so the competition of an auction will drive the price higher? Then I would push for auction. Does the client need discretion? Does their time frame not line up with our auction calendar? Then I would push for private sale. It is case by case, and ideally we put the object first and align it with what the client needs.
Say a family has just come into a large collection through an estate, or someone is looking at art as a source of liquidity. Where do they begin with you?
I would like to think a client comes to me with a bound appraisal or inventory, organized photos, clear provenance and certificates of authenticity. That is usually not the case. We can help a client build all of that, gather the information and organize it. Sometimes I work from photos texted from a phone. What I really need from the client is clarity of need. Are they looking for an idea of fair market value? Are they looking to sell? Do they need an insurance appraisal? Do they want to discuss private sale versus auction? We can help with all of it, but the one thing I really want a client to bring me is a clear sense of what their question is, so I can guide them.
Where does the lawyer fit in? Where does the lawyer add value, and where does the lawyer stand in the way?
The lawyer or the advisor adds a tremendous amount of value in getting that clarity, because sometimes the private client does not know what they need. The lawyer often tells us who the actual decision maker is. The lawyer can assure us of clear title. That is not something we want to find out moments before the sale. So the lawyer helps us clean those things up early, so we can get to a successful sale if that is the goal.
Daniel Novela: That is always one of our first concerns: who is conveying title, is it clear, and are there any encumbrances?
Part Two: What the Paperwork Reveals
Libia Elena Nahas asks Daniel Novela
When I start with a lawyer on a shared client, my first questions are who owns the property, what assurances we have, who the decision maker is, and what paper trail exists to make our research easier. Christie’s helps clients in many ways, usually when they want to transact: auction, private sale, online sales and appraisals. What happens when someone decides not to sell but still needs liquidity?
We see that. Sometimes it is a liquidity need, and sometimes clients are figuring out how to use their assets more efficiently. We see it with art, with collectibles, with watches and with cars. The main way we work with them is an art loan, a loan with the art as the collateral. I like to use these loans in all kinds of transactions. It could be liquidity, or a client who wants to buy more art. It could also be an acquisition where the client is a few million dollars short. Instead of mezzanine debt or acquisition financing, which is very expensive, an asset based loan costs much less. And there are a lot of options now, including you.
Libia Elena Nahas: Including Christie’s Art Finance.
Daniel Novela: That’s right. Like you said, it comes down to what the client truly needs, and giving them the options. If they are willing to give a blanket lien on all their assets, including the art, and to be personally liable, the cost will be lower, and that is a more traditional lender. If they want something ahead of an auction, or more flexibility, the auction houses now provide that. If they want a nonrecourse loan on a single piece and can let the lender hold the work, there are specialty lenders that do those deals. They are all priced according to risk.
From a legal standpoint, what do you want a client to be clear on before they buy?
Basel is a couple of weeks away, so take a purchase at the fair. Often all you get is an invoice. I want a clear description of the piece: the artist, the medium and when it was made. Without anything long, I also want it to say clearly that the seller owns the piece, has the right to sell it, and that it is free and clear of all liens. Then one sentence on the remedy: if that is not true, what happens? Does the client get their money back? And how are shipping and the other logistics handled? With an auction house I am less concerned, because there is a catalog and terms and conditions that are usually clearly spelled out. So this matters more for private sales. And on a significant purchase, in the millions, I would seriously consider a purchase agreement.
Wearing your legal hat, where does an auction house slow you down? What can we do better?
To your credit, most of the time it is not the auction house itself. It is the client’s understanding of how the process will work. In a recent sale in New York, it was not clear to the client whether delivery would be made in London or New York, because the piece was in London. That became a big issue. Once things are international, there is shipping, there are duties, there are all kinds of things. The other is negotiating rescission. If I represent the seller, the auction house can rescind the sale after the auction. I want clarity on that liability: how long is it hanging out there? I have had sales rescinded, and I know what that is like for the seller, because the public views the piece as sold. So all of those terms need to be very clear. The biggest thing for me as an attorney is making sure my client is clear on those terms, so they understand the risk and build it into their decision.
Libia Elena Nahas: From a client management perspective, nothing is worse than a client who is disappointed in the outcome of a consignment, and it usually comes from a lack of clarity. That is why I welcome the lawyer, the advisor or the client’s representative, to make sure the terms and the process are clear and that the client fully absorbs them.
Daniel Novela: I firmly believe the lawyer’s job is not to make the decision for the client, although sometimes we want to. Our job is to understand and explain the risk. The client decides how much risk to take, because only the client can make that decision. I said this to my students yesterday, at the last class of the semester at the University of Miami School of Law: if the lawyer understands the issue clearly, they should be able to explain it simply.
Libia Elena Nahas: When we talk about private sale versus auction, the client is often not clear on the pitfalls of each. They choose private sale because they think they can get a higher figure, but that exposes the work at a certain level. If it fails to sell and we then bring it to public auction, we lose some of that marketing moment, because the piece has already been offered privately.
Daniel Novela: I think most people would think private is private.
Libia Elena Nahas: It is. But we do private selling exhibitions, and we advertise private sale objects on our website, with express permission. We also do many private sales that are not advertised at all: the agreement is that we show the work to a set number of clients so it is not overexposed. There are a lot of nuances. We do our best to explain the possibilities, but the client really needs to absorb them.
Daniel Novela: You handle watches and luxury items as well as art. Does the market treat a piece that was already offered any differently outside of art?
Libia Elena Nahas: Not really. With editioned art, like prints and multiples, or a watch made in a production run, there is less of an exposure issue, because there are multiples out there. So it is not really luxury versus art.
Daniel Novela: But some watches can be very special. There is only one Paul Newman.
Libia Elena Nahas: And you helped educate me on that. You were our partner for our first watch exhibition. So much of what we do in the region is that. Not all of our clients travel to every sale site, so we are the link between our clients and the specialists, and between our clients and the partners in the region who can educate them on a topic.
Daniel Novela: That was through the NovelaWatch Collectors Club, which I started in 2015 with a small group of collectors on Miami Beach. Miami has become a much easier sell since then. With watches in particular, it was hard to get the big collectors, the right pieces and the right brands to come to Miami and pay attention. That is much easier now.
Libia Elena Nahas: We have a brick and mortar here, full time. We are not seasonal. We know the clients are here, and that they want education and programming. We are always happy to partner with you.